PCAOB Rule 3524 sets out specific communication and documentation requirements when a registered public accounting firm seeks audit committee preapproval to provide permissible tax services to an issuer audit client. The rule is not a general license to sell tax services to audit clients. It requires an informed review of proposed work, fees, related arrangements and possible threats to auditor independence before the service begins.
For CFOs, audit committee chairs and accounting firms, the practical question is twofold: Is the tax service permissible under the SEC and PCAOB independence framework, and has the audit committee received enough written information and discussion to make a defensible preapproval decision? This guide explains the rule, examples, a sample preapproval package and an implementation checklist.
What Is PCAOB Rule 3524?
Rule 3524, titled Audit Committee Pre-approval of Certain Tax Services, applies when a PCAOB-registered firm seeks audit committee preapproval to perform a permissible tax service for an issuer audit client. Under the rule, the firm must (1) describe specified arrangements in writing, (2) discuss potential independence effects with the audit committee, and (3) document the substance of that discussion. These are duties imposed on the audit firm in connection with the committee’s approval process.
The broader preapproval obligation derives from Section 10A of the Securities Exchange Act, as amended by Sarbanes-Oxley, and related SEC requirements. Rule 3524 supplements rather than replaces those requirements. The approval should occur before the service is performed, and the issuer’s documented policy should clarify who may grant approval and how it is retained.
Why the rule matters to public companies
Tax engagements can create independence questions when the same accounting firm also audits the company’s financial statements. Potential concerns include the auditor later evaluating the results of its own advice, performing a management function, advocating for the client, or participating in arrangements that create problematic incentives. The rule makes those issues visible to the audit committee, which has oversight responsibility for the independent auditor.
Does Rule 3524 apply to every tax consultant?
No. Rule 3524 specifically addresses registered public accounting firms seeking to provide permissible tax services to their issuer audit clients. A company’s use of an unrelated tax adviser does not, by itself, trigger this particular rule. Other professional, legal and governance rules may still apply to the engagement.
What Does PCAOB Rule 3524 Require Before Preapproval?
1. Describe the service scope and fee structure in writing
The written disclosure should identify the proposed work precisely: relevant entity or entities, tax periods, deliverables, nature of any advice or filings, anticipated timeline, and fee basis. Rule 3524 expressly requires the scope, fee structure, and relevant side letters, engagement-letter amendments, or other agreements with the audit client concerning the service, including oral arrangements, to be described in writing.
For example, “tax consulting services” is too broad for a useful review. A more informative description would specify preparation of a defined tax return for named subsidiaries, the responsible party, the expected fee approach and any exclusions. The rule does not impose a universal word count or require every proposal to follow one mandatory template.
2. Disclose relevant third-party compensation arrangements
The written package must also disclose compensation arrangements or other agreements between the firm (or its affiliate) and a third party, other than the audit client, relating to promoting, marketing or recommending a transaction covered by the proposed service. Referral agreements, referral fees and fee-sharing arrangements are examples. A stated absence of such arrangements can improve review clarity where that has been verified.
3. Discuss the effect on auditor independence
A packet sent by email is not a substitute for the required discussion. Rule 3524 directs the auditor to discuss with the audit committee how the proposed tax services could affect the firm’s independence. Participants should consider the actual scope and relevant prohibitions, not simply record that the engagement is “approved.” The auditor should be prepared to explain safeguards and any residual risk, without implying that safeguards override a prohibited activity.
4. Document the substance of the discussion
The firm must document the substance of its independence discussion with the committee. Useful records identify the date, participants, questions raised, the auditor’s explanations, matters escalated, the committee’s decision, and any scope or fee conditions. Corporate secretariat minutes and an auditor-side file memorandum can be complementary records, but neither should be assumed sufficient without reviewing what it actually documents.
Required element | Evidence to retain | Primary owner |
Service scope and fees | Dated written description, scope schedule and fee terms | Audit firm |
Side letters and amendments | Description of relevant agreements, including oral arrangements | Audit firm |
Third-party arrangements | Written details of referral / fee-sharing relationships if applicable | Audit firm |
Independence discussion | Meeting record or memorandum documenting substance | Audit firm |
Preapproval decision | Committee minutes, delegated approval or recorded resolution | Audit committee / company |
Which Tax Services Can an External Auditor Provide?
The crucial first step is to distinguish a service that is potentially permissible from a service prohibited regardless of approval. Section 201 of Sarbanes-Oxley and SEC Regulation S-X Rule 2-01 place restrictions on certain non-audit services; PCAOB Rules 3521 through 3523 add specific restrictions relevant to contingent fees, certain tax transactions and tax work for persons in financial reporting oversight roles.
Examples requiring a careful facts-and-circumstances review
Tax return preparation for the audit client: may be permissible in appropriate circumstances, subject to independence analysis and required preapproval.
Tax compliance support for a subsidiary: evaluate the subsidiary, nature of the work, deliverables and whether the service presents self-review or management-function concerns.
Tax advice relating to a proposed transaction: examine transaction structure, advocacy, third-party compensation, potential audit implications and restrictions on specified tax transactions.
Services for senior financial reporting personnel: separately examine Rule 3523, which limits certain personal tax services for people in financial reporting oversight roles and immediate family members.
Approval does not cure a prohibited service
Even unanimous audit committee approval does not make a prohibited tax service permissible. If a service creates an unacceptable conflict under SEC or PCAOB requirements, the company may need to engage a separate independent tax adviser instead. A tax arrangement should be assessed before work starts, not retroactively after the invoice is issued.
For a broader review of restricted and permitted activities, see MBP Global’s SEC auditor independence rules guide.
PCAOB Rule 3524 Compared With Rules 3520, 3523, 3525 and 3526
Rule | Core subject | Practical use |
3520 | General auditor independence obligation | Assess independence throughout the engagement |
3523 | Specified tax services for people in financial reporting oversight roles | Screen personal tax engagements and covered individuals |
3524 | Preapproval communications for permissible issuer-client tax services | Disclose arrangements, discuss independence, document discussion |
3525 | Preapproval communications for certain ICFR-related non-audit services | Check separate ICFR service disclosures and safeguards |
3526 | Audit committee communications concerning firm independence | Address initial and at-least-annual independence communications |
Rules 3524 and 3526 are not interchangeable: Rule 3524 concerns specific proposed tax engagements; Rule 3526 covers broader independence relationships and communications. Similarly, Rule 3525 addresses a different category of permissible non-audit services related to internal control over financial reporting.
For the overall framework, consult MBP Global’s PCAOB independence rules overview.
Step-by-Step PCAOB Rule 3524 Preapproval Workflow
Identify the exact proposed tax service, affected entities, expected deliverables and tax periods.
Screen the engagement for prohibited services, contingent-fee restrictions, financial reporting oversight roles and other independence threats.
Prepare the written 3524 disclosure, including scope, fee structure, side agreements and relevant third-party compensation arrangements.
Deliver the packet to the audit committee or appropriately authorized decision-maker sufficiently before the planned start date.
Hold a substantive discussion about independence implications; resolve outstanding questions and revise the scope where needed.
Record the committee’s preapproval and any permitted conditions, including fee ceilings or approval limits where applicable.
Document the discussion, retain version-controlled evidence and monitor subsequent changes to scope, fees and relationships.
An organization should set its own internal turnaround time and escalation protocol. Rule 3524 itself does not prescribe a universal 30-day or annual tax-service preapproval deadline. A recurring annual review may be an effective governance practice, but a new or materially changed engagement still needs evaluation under the applicable approval policy.
Sample PCAOB Rule 3524 Preapproval Letter Outline
The following is an illustrative internal drafting structure, not an official PCAOB-approved form. Counsel and the independence team should adapt it to the circumstances.
Letter section | Suggested content |
Request heading | Issuer, audit firm, proposed service, request date, intended start date |
Scope | Entities, tax periods, specific deliverables, exclusions, required client responsibilities |
Fee arrangement | Fixed, hourly or other permissible fee structure; estimate and expense terms |
Related agreements | Side letters, amendments and other relevant written or oral terms |
Third-party compensation | Disclose any covered referral or fee-sharing arrangements, or verified none |
Independence assessment | Identify applicable constraints and explain potential effects on independence |
Discussion record | Date, attendees, topics discussed and unresolved questions |
Approval record | Committee action, conditions, scope and approval date |
Example of an appropriately scoped request
A registered audit firm requests approval to prepare specified federal and state income tax returns for named U.S. subsidiaries for a defined year, using client-approved financial records. The packet identifies the agreed fixed fee, any authorized out-of-pocket expenses, whether side agreements exist, and the absence or presence of covered third-party compensation. The team separately explains how management will retain responsibility for all tax elections and accounting decisions. The audit committee discusses self-review risks and records its approval or refusal before work begins.
Example of a weak request
An audit firm sends a one-line email stating “Please approve all current and future tax work,” without disclosing services, fee structure or additional arrangements. The committee replies “Approved,” and no independence discussion is recorded. This approach would not satisfy the specific communication and documentation elements of Rule 3524.
Audit Committee Tax-Service Preapproval Checklist
Confirm the audit firm and client are within the rule’s issuer-audit context.
Define the tax service, affected entities and tax periods.
Confirm that the service is otherwise permissible under SEC and PCAOB rules.
Obtain a written statement of scope and fee structure.
Identify all relevant side letters, amendments and other agreements.
Obtain disclosure of covered third-party referral or fee-sharing arrangements.
Discuss self-review, advocacy, management-function and other independence threats.
Confirm management retains decisions, records and responsibility.
Record the actual preapproval decision before service commencement.
Document the substance of the independence discussion.
Assign responsibility for monitoring fee or scope changes.
Archive records in an accessible, appropriately controlled repository.
Common Rule 3524 Mistakes and How to Avoid Them
Treating preapproval as a blanket exception
An audit committee policy may describe classes of permissible engagements, but the auditor still must satisfy Rule 3524’s applicable communications when seeking approval for tax work. An approval policy cannot nullify prohibited-service rules.
Ignoring fee amendments and side agreements
Scope changes and fee revisions can alter independence considerations. Route material changes for reevaluation and record why any additional approval is or is not required under the company’s policy and applicable rules.
Failing to document the discussion
A disclosure packet, calendar invitation or short “approved” response does not necessarily show what independence risks were discussed. Retain a record of the substantive exchange.
Confusing auditor advice with management responsibility
Management should decide whether to pursue tax strategies, approve filings and make financial reporting judgments. The audit firm cannot assume management functions merely because the committee has granted preapproval.
How Audit Committees and CFOs Can Strengthen Their Process
A consistent preapproval program usually benefits from a service catalog, approval owner, documented independence screening, versioned engagement letters and a log of committee decisions. Simple shared tracking may be sufficient for a low-volume issuer; more complex groups may benefit from a controlled workflow system, provided the tool facilitates rather than replaces substantive professional judgment.
When evaluating software or external advisory support, ask whether it can record both the written service disclosures and the discussion/approval history; retain attachments and amendments; identify the entities affected; and flag when a new engagement or fee revision requires reassessment. An automation tool cannot itself determine that a service is legally permissible.
Audit committees evaluating a firm’s governance and independence practices may also review MBP Global’s audit firm RFP and SEC auditor selection guide.
Frequently Asked Questions About PCAOB Rule 3524
What is PCAOB Rule 3524 in simple terms?
It requires a PCAOB-registered audit firm seeking approval for permissible tax services to an issuer audit client to provide specified written disclosures, discuss possible independence effects with the audit committee and document the substance of that discussion.
Does audit committee preapproval make every tax service permissible?
No. The underlying service must independently comply with applicable SEC and PCAOB independence restrictions.
Does Rule 3524 require the engagement letter itself?
The rule requires descriptions of the scope, fee structure and relevant side letters, amendments and other agreements. It does not universally require the audit firm to provide the entire tax engagement letter as the only way to comply.
Can the CFO approve tax services on behalf of the audit committee?
Preapproval must follow applicable audit committee and SEC delegation requirements. Management cannot simply substitute its own approval for the committee’s statutory responsibility.
Does the rule require disclosure of referral fees?
Yes, when covered third-party compensation or other agreements relate to promoting, marketing or recommending a transaction covered by the proposed service.
What is the difference between Rule 3524 and Rule 3526?
Rule 3524 addresses specific tax-service preapproval communications; Rule 3526 addresses broader initial and recurring independence communications with the audit committee.
How often must a Rule 3524 request be approved?
Preapproval must precede the proposed service under applicable rules. A company may maintain annual approval cycles, but no single universal annual timing rule applies to every tax engagement under Rule 3524.
What happens if the auditor starts work before approval?
The company and audit firm should promptly assess the facts, independence consequences and appropriate reporting or remediation steps with qualified counsel and independence specialists; a retrospective signature does not necessarily cure a failure.
Can a private company use this checklist?
Yes, as a governance resource, although Rule 3524 specifically targets issuer audit clients of registered public accounting firms.
What should the audit committee retain?
A dated disclosure package, evidence of discussion, approval decision and conditions, material scope amendments, and the firm’s record of the independence discussion.
Discuss Audit Independence and Permissible Tax Services With MBP Global
When an SEC issuer is evaluating its independent auditor, tax-service arrangements should be reviewed early rather than just before year-end. Appropriate service scope, independence screening and defensible committee communications can help reduce avoidable uncertainty during the audit process.
MBP Global LLP works with companies navigating SEC reporting and independent audit requirements. Explore its Audit & Assurance Services and contact the team to discuss the appropriate engagement structure, subject to applicable independence and professional requirements.


