PCAOB Inspection Reports: How to Read Them When Evaluating an Audit Firm

PCAOB Inspection Reports: How to Read Them When Evaluating an Audit Firm

var(--variable-LoqRZ1RA_)
var(--variable-LoqRZ1RA_)

PCAOB inspection reports are a valuable due-diligence resource when an audit committee is choosing, retaining, or replacing an independent auditor. They reveal findings from portions of selected audit engagements and can highlight concerns involving audit evidence, accounting estimates, internal controls, independence, and firm quality-control systems. But the reports are not simple pass-or-fail grades - and a high deficiency percentage does not necessarily reflect the quality of every audit performed by a firm.

For CFOs, controllers, board members, and IPO candidates, the practical question is not “Which firm has the smallest number?” It is “What do the findings reveal about risks relevant to our engagement, how did the firm respond, and does the proposed engagement team have the capability and independence we require?” This guide explains how to locate and interpret reports, compare firms fairly, and turn the findings into an actionable auditor-selection review.

What Are PCAOB Inspection Reports?

The Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB) inspects registered accounting firms to assess compliance with relevant PCAOB and SEC requirements and professional standards. The PCAOB examines selected audit work and aspects of the firm’s quality-control system. A public inspection report describes observations from that inspection; the complete set of the firm’s audits is not inspected.

Who is inspected, and how often?

Firms issuing audit reports for more than 100 issuers in the prior calendar year are generally inspected annually. Firms issuing reports for at least one but no more than 100 issuers over the relevant three-year period generally face inspections at least once every three years. There are additional rules and special situations, including firms playing a substantial role in audits.

Are PCAOB inspections equivalent to audit opinions?

No. An inspection report assesses specified audit work and firm practices; it does not replace an audit report on any company’s financial statements. An inspection deficiency generally does not, by itself, establish that an issuer’s financial statements were materially misstated or that the audit opinion was incorrect. Nor does an inspection without reported findings guarantee future audit quality.

Where to find official reports

Begin with the PCAOB Firm Inspection Reports database. Search the exact legal entity name and review each available year and country. The PCAOB Registered Firms directory verifies firm registration, while AuditorSearch can provide insight into identified issuer engagements and engagement partners. Cross-check any inspection narrative against the report itself rather than relying solely on a third-party summary.

PCAOB Firm Inspection Reports  https://pcaobus.org/oversight/inspections/firm-inspection-reports

PCAOB Basics of Inspections  https://pcaobus.org/oversight/inspections/basics-of-inspections

How to Read PCAOB Inspection Reports: Part I.A, Part I.B and Part II

The PCAOB’s report format separates significant engagement-level findings from other compliance observations and confidential quality-control criticisms. Audit committees should understand what each section can - and cannot - tell them.

Section

What it generally covers

What an audit committee should do

Overview / historical tables

Inspection scope, selected audits, historical results and context.

Record inspection year, sample size and changes in the firm’s issuer population.

Part I.A

Deficiencies where the PCAOB found the firm lacked sufficient appropriate audit evidence at the time it issued its report.

Study affected audit areas, severity, recurrence and firm responses.

Part I.B

Other instances of noncompliance with PCAOB rules or standards not directly about sufficiency of evidence supporting the opinion.

Identify independence, communications, documentation or other relevant patterns.

Part II

Quality-control criticisms and potential defects; generally confidential initially.

Ask management or the auditor about systemic improvements; do not presume a blank public Part II means no concerns.

 

Part I.A: Insufficient audit evidence

A Part I.A finding indicates that, when the auditor issued its opinion, the audit work reviewed did not provide sufficient appropriate evidence to support the relevant opinion or part of the work. Examples may involve testing revenue, evaluating estimates, or auditing internal control over financial reporting (ICFR). The finding does not automatically mean the financial statements were wrong; the firm may have performed additional procedures after the inspection team identified the issue. Review the precise description and response in the report.

Part I.B: Other noncompliance observations

Part I.B includes observed instances of noncompliance that are distinct from the evidence-sufficiency issues reported in Part I.A. Audit committees should consider whether these observations involve recurring audit procedures, communication requirements, professional responsibilities, or other matters connected to their issuer.

Part II: Quality-control criticisms and the 12-month rule

Part II addresses criticisms or potential defects in a firm’s system of quality control. These sections generally are not public when the report is first issued. If the firm does not satisfactorily address the criticisms within 12 months after the report’s initial issuance, the PCAOB may make the relevant criticisms public. A publicly undisclosed Part II is not proof that a firm’s quality-control system received a clean bill of health.

The PCAOB reviews whether corrective actions are relevant, properly designed, implemented, and effective. An audit committee can ask a candidate firm to explain its approach to remediation without requesting confidential information that the firm is unable to disclose.

What Does the PCAOB Inspection Deficiency Rate Mean?

The PCAOB defines a Part I.A deficiency rate as the number of issuer audits included in Part I.A divided by the number of issuer audits reviewed. For example, if 4 of 10 selected audits appear in Part I.A, the displayed rate is 40%. That is an illustration of the calculation - not a finding that 40% of all firm audits are deficient.

Why a deficiency rate is not a firm-wide error rate

The PCAOB selects engagements using both risk-based and random methods, with a substantial risk-based component. Its teams generally inspect only selected portions of those engagements. As a result, the sample is not necessarily representative of the entire firm’s issuer-audit population, and a percentage should not be extrapolated to all engagements.

Why comparisons across firms and years require context

Inspection samples may differ in size, issuer profile, transaction complexity, audit areas reviewed, inspection focus, and the proportion of risk-based selections. A firm with only a few inspected audits can show large year-to-year changes due to one additional finding. Comparing a large multi-industry firm with a smaller specialized issuer firm solely by raw percentage is therefore unreliable.

What to compare instead

  • Recurring subject matter: revenue recognition, estimates, ICFR, engagement quality review, or audit evidence.

  • Whether the finding relates to your company’s business model or accounting risks.

  • The report years and audit periods inspected - not just the publication date.

  • The number and nature of engagements selected and any changes in scope.

  • The candidate’s concrete remediation actions and subsequent inspection patterns.

  • The proposed engagement partner’s relevant issuer experience and actual staffing plan.

Seven Steps to Evaluate an Audit Firm Using PCAOB Inspection Reports

Step 1: Confirm the exact legal entity and registration

Verify the firm’s legal name, PCAOB registration, offices and engagement structure. Global-network members may be separate legal entities with distinct inspection histories. Do not substitute the report of a similarly named network firm for the entity that would sign your audit opinion.

Step 2: Read at least the recent available reports

Look at multiple reports where available. Note inspection year, report publication date, sample size and whether the firm is inspected annually or triennially. A three-year gap in reports does not automatically indicate noncompliance for a triennially inspected firm.

Step 3: Map findings to your financial reporting risks

A SaaS issuer may prioritize revenue recognition, contract accounting and IT-dependent controls; a financial services issuer may prioritize valuations, credit estimates and financial instruments. An IPO candidate may require expertise in equity transactions, historical financial statements and complex SEC reporting. Compare inspection themes with your own risk register.

Step 4: Ask for remediation evidence and process changes

Ask how the firm investigated the underlying causes, revised methodology, strengthened supervision, updated training, implemented monitoring, and assessed results. Distinguish a planned measure from an action that has operated and been tested. The firm may need to respect confidentiality limits, so seek an appropriate substantive explanation rather than the disclosure of nonpublic inspection material.

Step 5: Evaluate the proposed partner and specialists

Firm-wide inspection history is only one input. Request the proposed engagement partner’s SEC issuer experience, industry background, specialist availability, partner involvement and quality review plan. PCAOB AuditorSearch and public company filings can help corroborate portions of this record.

Step 6: Verify independence, timing and capacity

The audit committee should separately evaluate SEC and PCAOB independence requirements, prohibited services, relevant relationships and required committee communications. Ask how the firm will staff complex audit areas and meet Form 10-K or IPO deadlines; inspection history cannot substitute for these checks.

Step 7: Record an evidence-based decision

Use a consistent shortlist scorecard, note specific inspection concerns, record the responses received, and document why the candidate is suitable. For listed issuers, the audit committee has applicable responsibilities for auditor appointment, compensation, retention and oversight. Keep the decision focused on audit quality, fit and independence - not simply a league table.

Audit Committee Scorecard: Practical PCAOB Inspection Evaluation Template

The following weights are illustrative internal selection criteria, not PCAOB or SEC-mandated scoring. A candidate that fails mandatory registration or independence checks should not proceed based on a high numerical score.

Evaluation factor

Illustrative weight

Evidence / question

PCAOB registration and independence

Pass / fail

Verify legal entity, SEC/PCAOB independence and eligibility.

Relevant inspection findings and remediation

25%

Nature, recurrence, latest results, credible corrective actions.

Comparable SEC issuer and industry experience

25%

Actual issuer assignments and complex accounting expertise.

Partner, specialists and quality oversight

20%

Named team, supervisor involvement, engagement quality review.

Capacity and timetable

15%

Detailed staffing and realistic filing milestones.

Audit committee communication

10%

Escalation process, issue resolution, independence updates.

Proposal transparency

5%

Scope, fee assumptions, exclusions and change requests.

 

Questions to ask during finalist interviews

  • Which inspection findings most closely relate to our reporting risks, and what did you change?

  • What evidence shows those changes are operating effectively?

  • What percentage of the proposed partner’s time will be spent on our engagement?

  • How are difficult accounting judgments and ICFR findings escalated?

  • How has your quality-control program changed following inspections?

  • Have inspection-related matters influenced your current audit methodology or supervision?

  • Which specialists will handle revenue, tax, valuation, IT controls or cross-border components?

  • How do you maintain independence and communicate with the audit committee?

  • How do the proposed fees and timeline reflect our accounting and reporting risks?

PCAOB Inspection Report Checklist for CFOs and Audit Committees

  • Confirm the precise legal firm and its current PCAOB registration.

  • Locate reports and record both inspection year and release date.

  • Read the inspection scope and the number of selected issuer audits.

  • Review Part I.A and Part I.B observations separately.

  • Do not equate a confidential Part II with absence of quality-control concerns.

  • Note trends but avoid treating deficiency rates as overall firm ratings.

  • Identify recurring deficiencies related to the issuer’s financial reporting risks.

  • Ask for specific remediation and monitoring actions.

  • Check relevant public disciplinary information separately from inspection reports.

  • Assess the proposed partner, specialists, firm capacity and independence.

  • Normalize RFP scope and fee assumptions.

  • Document the selection or retention rationale and committee approvals.

Common Mistakes When Comparing PCAOB Audit Firms

Treating the lowest deficiency rate as a universal winner

The inspected engagement sample is not a representative firm-wide quality score. Evaluate the underlying deficiencies and engagement fit instead.

Assuming Part I.A means an issuer must restate

A finding about insufficient audit evidence is not automatically a finding of material misstatement, an incorrect audit opinion, or a mandatory re-audit. Any subsequent actions depend on the circumstances.

Ignoring small samples and inspection timing

One additional finding can produce a large rate change when the denominator is small. A recent publication can also relate to audit work performed in an earlier period.

Confusing inspection findings with disciplinary sanctions

Inspections and enforcement proceedings are different processes. A reported deficiency is not itself a final enforcement sanction. Review disciplinary orders separately where relevant.

Failing to connect findings to your own risks

An audit committee should explore whether the findings implicate revenue recognition, valuation, ICFR or other areas that are material to its business and proposed engagement.

How PCAOB Inspection Reports Fit Into an SEC Auditor RFP

An audit firm RFP should ask bidders to identify their relevant PCAOB-registered legal entities, describe inspection findings pertinent to the proposed work, summarize remediation practices within confidentiality limits, and show how engagement quality is supervised. It should also require independence confirmations, qualified engagement partner biographies, audit scope, timeline, and fee transparency.

An inspection review should complement - and never replace - the independent auditor selection process. MBP Global’s related guides explain the selection mechanics and PCAOB registration checks in more detail:

Audit Firm RFP: How to Choose an SEC Auditor  https://www.mbpgloballlp.com/insight-and-news/choose-sec-auditor-audit-firm-rfp

PCAOB Registered Audit Firms: How to Find and Evaluate the Right Auditor  https://www.mbpgloballlp.com/insight-and-news/pcaob-registered-audit-firms

How to Choose an Auditor for Pre-IPO Audit Readiness  https://www.mbpgloballlp.com/insight-and-news/how-to-choose-independent-auditor-pre-ipo

SEC Auditor Independence Rules  https://www.mbpgloballlp.com/insight-and-news/sec-auditor-independence-rules

When Should a Company Reconsider Its Current External Auditor?

A recurring inspection pattern that relates to the company’s most significant reporting risks may warrant follow-up, but not an automatic change of auditor. Audit committees may also reconsider an engagement when relevant independence issues arise, technical capacity no longer matches the issuer’s complexity, communication deteriorates, or the team cannot reliably meet reporting requirements. For an actual auditor replacement, assess successor-auditor procedures and applicable Form 8-K Item 4.01 disclosures with legal counsel and the firms involved.

Companies should ask for a written, engagement-specific audit plan before making a decision. The objective is to select a firm capable of producing a high-quality, independent audit - not simply to avoid an unfavorable headline about a past inspection.

How MBP Global LLP Can Support Public Company Auditor Evaluation

MBP Global LLP provides audit and assurance services to public companies and businesses preparing for U.S. capital markets transactions. An audit committee considering MBP Global or any other candidate should independently check the precise signing entity’s PCAOB registration, available inspection history, independence, engagement resources and relevance to its reporting circumstances.

For audit committees preparing a shortlist, reviewing an incumbent auditor, or planning an IPO, MBP Global’s public-company audit resources offer a starting point for discussing scope, applicable standards, timelines and firm suitability. Any representation about the firm’s inspection record or outcomes should be supported by the PCAOB’s current public records rather than assumed from marketing materials.

MBP Global LLP – Audit & Assurance Services  https://www.mbpgloballlp.com/audit-assurance-sevices

MBP Global LLP – Contact and Firm Information  https://www.mbpgloballlp.com/

Next step: If your company is comparing independent audit firms, prepare your issuer profile, regulatory timetable, known financial reporting risks and audit RFP criteria before requesting an engagement discussion.

Frequently Asked Questions About PCAOB Inspection Reports

Are PCAOB inspection reports public?

The public portion of issued PCAOB firm inspection reports is available through the official database. Certain quality-control criticisms are initially withheld and may later become public under the 12-month remediation provisions.

What is a PCAOB Part I.A deficiency?

It is an inspection observation that the audit firm did not obtain sufficient appropriate audit evidence, at the time it issued its report, to support the relevant audit opinion or work reviewed.

What is the difference between Part I.A and Part I.B?

Part I.A covers significant evidence-sufficiency deficiencies; Part I.B generally covers other observed noncompliance with PCAOB standards or rules.

What does PCAOB Part II mean?

Part II concerns quality-control criticisms or potential defects and is generally nonpublic when an inspection report is first issued. Certain criticisms may be made public if not satisfactorily addressed within 12 months.

Does a high deficiency rate mean the audit firm is unsafe to hire?

Not by itself. Inspection selections are not a representative sample of all audits. Committees should study the types of deficiencies, repeat findings, remediation actions and engagement-team fit.

Do PCAOB inspection findings require financial restatements?

Not automatically. A deficiency does not by itself establish a material misstatement or an incorrect opinion; specific additional audit work or reporting actions depend on the facts.

How often does the PCAOB inspect firms?

Firms with more than 100 issuer audit reports in the prior calendar year are generally inspected annually; firms with 100 or fewer relevant issuer reports are generally inspected at least triennially.

How can I compare Big Four and mid-tier firms?

Review the same regulatory eligibility and independence criteria, then consider comparable audit-risk findings, the assigned partner and team, industry expertise, specialist support and reporting capacity.

Can a firm have no publicly available inspection report?

Yes. Registration alone does not mean the firm has already been subject to a public inspection report. Check the firm’s activity, inspection cycle and official directory before drawing conclusions.

Should our audit committee use inspection reports in an RFP?

Yes, as one source of due diligence alongside registration, independence, technical experience, staffing, communications, audit approach and price transparency.

Conclusion: Use PCAOB Inspection Reports as Evidence, Not a Ranking Table

PCAOB inspection reports can improve auditor selection when they are read in context. Review the report’s scope, differentiate Part I.A from Part I.B and confidential Part II, assess risk-based sampling limitations, and ask candidates to explain relevant findings and remediation. Combine this work with evidence on independence, issuer experience, engagement leadership and capacity. The result is a more defensible audit committee decision based on your company’s financial reporting needs.